Commentary:

Carl's performance in Bounty mode shows a mixed but generally consistent trend across different trophy ranges. His win rate fluctuates between 43.5% and 63.5%, with a slight upward curve at higher trophies, particularly showing a strong peak around the 1100 trophy bucket. While he doesn't consistently outperform the majority of players in any single tier, his performance remains relatively stable, suggesting that Carl can be a viable option for players looking to climb but may require some adaptation to perform well in higher-tier matches. Mastery could offer significant rewards, especially at higher trophies, but he may not be the easiest brawler to pick up due to varying effectiveness across different skill levels.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Brawl Ball shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase. At lower trophies, his win rate hovers around 45%, indicating moderate success. However, as the trophy buckets rise, so does his win rate, peaking at 89.6% in the highest tier (1800+). This suggests that Carl becomes significantly stronger in higher-level play, where skill and strategy have a greater impact. While he may not be the easiest brawler to pick up due to lower-tier performance, mastering Carl can lead to strong results in competitive play.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Gem Grab shows a generally consistent win rate across all trophy brackets, with a slight upward trend as trophies increase. While his win rate remains below 50% in the lower and mid-tier brackets, it significantly improves in higher tiers, reaching over 80% in the top 1600 trophy bracket. This suggests that Carl may be more effective for players with higher skill levels or experience, indicating that he might be harder to pick up for beginners but can be a strong choice for those who master his mechanics.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Heist mode shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates gradually rising from 39.9% at lower trophies to a peak of 72.2% at the highest trophy bucket (1200). While his overall win rate remains below 60% across most tiers, he demonstrates strong potential in high-tier matches, suggesting that Carl can be effective when played by skilled players. However, his performance does not consistently stand out across all levels, indicating that mastering him may require significant effort and strategic play to fully leverage his strengths in Heist.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Hot Zone shows a generally consistent but modest win rate across all trophy buckets, with some notable improvements at higher trophies. While his win rate remains below 60% in most brackets, it peaks at 62.2% in the highest trophy bucket (1100+), suggesting that Carl can be effective when played by more experienced players. However, his overall performance indicates that he may not be the strongest choice for beginners or those looking for a high win rate consistently across all skill levels. Mastery could provide an edge, but he might not be the easiest brawler to pick up and succeed with right away.

Commentary:

Carl performs consistently across all trophy buckets in Knockout mode, with win rates generally hovering around or slightly above 50%. His performance peaks at higher trophy levels, where he achieves a win rate of over 60% in the 1100 and 1200 trophy buckets. While not dominant, Carl shows enough reliability to be viable in competitive play, especially as trophies increase. He is not overly difficult to pick up, but mastery may offer more significant rewards at higher levels.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Wipeout shows a mixed trend across different trophy brackets. He performs reasonably well in lower-tier matches, with a win rate above 50% in the 0-100 and 500-600 trophy ranges. However, his win rate drops significantly in mid-tier brackets (200-400 trophies), where it falls below 45%. In higher tiers (800+ trophies), he shows a slight improvement again, with win rates hovering around or above 55%. This suggests that Carl may be more effective for players at lower and very high skill levels but struggles in the mid-tier range. Whether he's worth mastering depends on a player’s current trophy level and ability to adapt his playstyle accordingly. He might be easier to pick up for beginners, but could present challenges for those aiming to compete consistently in higher tiers.