Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Bounty mode shows a gradual decline in win rate as trophy levels increase, with her strongest showing at lower tiers. While she maintains a decent win rate in the highest tier (around 48.5%), it drops significantly in mid-tier ranges. This suggests that Melodie may struggle against more experienced players but can be effective for those starting out or playing at lower levels. Her overall consistency is moderate, indicating she might not be the best choice for high-level competition, though she remains playable across most skill brackets.

Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Brawl Ball shows a generally consistent win rate across most trophy brackets, with a slight decline as her trophy count increases. However, she demonstrates a notable improvement at higher trophies (1300 and above), where her win rate peaks over 84%. This suggests that while Melodie may not be the strongest choice for casual players, she can become highly effective once mastered, particularly in competitive scenarios. Her performance indicates that she might require more skill to play optimally, making her a brawler that could be worth mastering for those looking to excel at higher levels of play.

Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Gem Grab shows a generally consistent but not outstanding win rate across different trophy brackets. She performs best at the lowest and highest tiers, with win rates above 60% in both the 0-100 and 1100+ trophy ranges, suggesting she can be effective for players just starting out or those at the top of the competitive ladder. However, her win rate dips below 50% in several mid-tier brackets, indicating that she may struggle in more competitive environments. While Melodie is not difficult to pick up, her overall performance suggests she may not be the most reliable choice for consistent success in Gem Grab unless played at a very high or very low skill level.

Commentary:

Melodie performs best in the highest trophy buckets, with win rates exceeding 80% in top tiers (1500+ trophies), suggesting she excels when played by highly skilled players. However, her win rate drops significantly at lower and mid-tier levels, indicating that she may be less effective for casual or new players. This pattern suggests Melodie is a brawler that becomes increasingly powerful with mastery but may be challenging to pick up due to her lower performance in less experienced hands.

Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Hot Zone shows a consistent but gradually declining win rate as trophy levels increase, starting strong at 64% for lower-tier players and dropping to around 43-46% in the higher tiers. While she remains playable across all skill levels, her effectiveness diminishes significantly against stronger opponents. This suggests that Melodie may be easier to pick up but less rewarding to master, as her impact tends to wane in more competitive play.

Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Knockout is fairly consistent across most trophy ranges, with win rates generally hovering around 45-53%. She performs slightly better in the lower and mid-tier trophies, but her win rate dips below 50% in higher tiers. While she shows potential in certain brackets, her overall consistency suggests that she may not be the strongest pick for competitive play, though she can still be viable with proper positioning and teamwork. Mastery could offer some advantage, but she may not stand out as a top-tier choice.

Commentary:

Melodie's performance in Wipeout varies across different trophy brackets, with win rates fluctuating between 34.9% and 54.3%. She shows stronger consistency in the mid-tier brackets (200–600 trophies), but her overall win rate remains below 50% in most ranges. While she has moments of success, especially around 200–600 trophies, her performance does not consistently stand out across all skill levels. This suggests that Melodie may be challenging to master and less reliable as a top-tier pick in Wipeout.